ONE OF AUSTRALIA'S FAVOURITE SOURCES FOR FILM, DVD AND BLU-RAY NEWS AND REVIEWS













HKDL Source
MovieXpress
Rent DVDs online - Webflicks
Adam Internet
Please Support us by Visiting our Sponsors




Star Wars - Episode V - The Empire Strikes Back
Fox
Released on 22-Sep-2004

Reviewed by Mark Mills on 14-Sep-2004

Printable
Version



Disc Specifications
Region Coding 4
Picture Format 2.35:1 widescreen 16:9 enhanced
Audio Format(s) English DD 2
English DD EX 5.1
Disc-type Dual-layer
Single-sided
Non-flipper
Macrovision Yes
Subtitles English for the hearing impaired
Danish
Finnish
Norwegian
Swedish
Running Time 122 minutes (PAL)
Chapters 50
Trailer(s)
Commentry Track George Lucas, Ivan Kershner, Carrie Fisher, Ben Burtt, and Dennis Muren
Other Extras See Bonus Disc Review
Starring Mark Hamill
Harrison Ford
Carrie Fisher
Peter Cushing
Alec Guinness
Anthony Daniels
Kenny Baker
Peter Mayhew
David Prowse
James Earl Jones
Classification Rated (PG)
RRP $ 69.95

Disc Rating
Plot
Video quality
Audio quality
Extras
Overall

Mark's Recent Reviews
1.
The League Of Extraordinary Gentlemen (2-Disc)
2.
Hollywood Homicide
3.
Mel Gibson's Best
4.
The One (Superbit)
5.
xXx (Superbit)


THE MOVIE

Disclaimer: This section is more of an editorial about Star Wars and my personal history and opinions of this film than the usual 'review' we do of the plot lines.

Despite the fact I was only 1 1/2 years old when The Empire Strikes Back was first released in May 1980, the whole Star Wars Trilogy holds a fond place in my childhood, along with other memories such as He-Man and The Transformers. As a kid I had all the toys, the Hoth Ice Base, Luke, Leia, Han, Vader, Obi-Wan, the Ewoks (yes, as a kid I liked the Ewoks.. but my opinion has changed a little since them) and all the cool vehicles. I even had a huge mural painted on my bedroom wall of the Rebel Alliance attacking the Death Star. When I say huge I mean it, it was twice the size of me! I was Star Wars crazy.

Unfortunately in my early teens my parents decided 'Mark doesn’t need these toys anymore, let’s sell them at the local Trash and Treasure Market along with all the other cool stuff he has'. As you can imagine, to this day I still have not forgiven them for doing this!


Anyway, now I am 26 years old and I must say that the first watching of The Empire Strikes Back on DVD is a near religious experience. When the music started and I saw that yellow text start scrolling up the screen I could not help but sit there with the biggest grin on my face in a long time. I had friends who insisted they be present for the first spin in my DVD player of this disc; and as soon as that familiar music started the room fell silent, everyone knew they were watching a piece of cinematic history. When that Imperial droid probe crashes into Hoth at the start of the film you could hear everyone stop breathing for a split second in the sheer awe of seeing and hearing this classic film on our beloved format.

Everyone knows the story of the whole Star Wars Trilogy, even if they are one of the few that have never seen the films. One of my good friends has never seen Episode IV, V, or VI. What was his reasoning? He is waiting to watch them all, and I quote, 'in order'. The amusing thing is that this fact actually cost him a job at one stage a couple years ago (and I am not joking!). But I digress, back onto talking about the actual film. After the events in Episode IV: A New Hope, the rebel alliance is hiding out on the ice planet of Hoth. When the Imperial forces discover their location they barely manage to escape. After their escape, Luke and R2D2 then goes to seek out the Jedi Master Yoda to complete his training on the swap planet Dagobah while Leia, Han, Chewbacca, C3PO and head in the Millennium Falcon to the Cloud City above the planet Bespin and the apparently welcoming arms of Lando Calrissian. Darth Vader manages to capture the people on the Cloud City and Luke senses a disturbance in the force and rushes to the Cloud City against Yoda's advice. It is here we have an epic clash of Luke vs. Vader and learn some shocking secrets.


There has been a whole lot of fuss created over the fact that the films presented on these DVD’s are not the ‘original’ films. Apparently George Lucas was never happy with the technology available in the late 1970’s and early 80’s that he used to create what is considered his masterpieces. In 1997 he decided that the technology was available to revisit these films and in his eye finish the project, dubbing them the Special Editions and giving them both a theatrical and video release. This caused uproar from the fans whom were not happy with the changes that were made, claiming that it degraded the magic of the film. Well this version of The Empire Strikes Back is not the Special Edition that die-hard fan’s love to hate… It is more something like a Super-Special-Edition, there is even more slight changes to annoy those die-hard fans. Luckily I am not one of those people, I believe that the films are George Lucas’ vision that he wants to give to us, and this is his definitive version (for now at least!). I actually believe it is sort of fun seeing the changes and if you can spot them all. That’s just my opinion, it seems everyone has their own opinion on this topic.

Saying that, I really have no problems with the insertion of special effects, Greedo shooting first in A New Hope, the Emperor being changed to Ian McDiarmid, or Vader being portrayed as Hayden Christensen at the end of Jedi. But one thing that has slightly annoyed me is the dialogue between Vader and the Emperor changing, I guess it does fit in now that we have Episodes I and II, and the upcoming Episode III, but it just sticks out as major change and made me do a double-take and re-watch the scene a couple times.

THE TRANSFER

Video:

As you can see from the included screenshots (click on them for larger versions), the picture looks great. After previously only watching VHS copies of the film that most likely would have been worn out after repeat viewings over the years, or only having seen it on broadcast television, you will definitely be impressed by the quality of the video footage.


Presented in the original aspect ratio on a dual layer disc, there has been a whole lot of tender loving care given to the restoration and transfer process of this film. If you have just purchased a large screen plasma television, you really cannot go wrong with using this film as a demo of your expensive purchase to your friends, but for those with 68cm televisions or smaller it is still a super-sweet treat for the eyes.

Split over 50 chapters, it is easy to jump to your favourite part in the film, but the layer change in the 27th chapter caused a slight pause on my Sony DVP-725 player. Luckily its not too noticeable or in a high action part of the film.

I did not spot one single flaw in the print; there were no spots, specks, scratches or any of those nasty artefacts that we sometimes talk about.

Audio:

I mentioned earlier about seeing and hearing the Imperial droid probe crashing at Hoth for the first time causing some breath-holding experiences to occur, you just have to hear this to know what I am speaking about. As with the video quality, you have never heard The Empire Strikes Back sound this good before!


The surround sound is used to excellent effect, and boy does the subwoofer get a work out. The rumble of the Star Destroyers, the indescribable sound of lightsabers, the tweeting and beeping of R2D2, it is all superbly represented here on this one small shiny disc in an excellent Dolby Digital 5.1 EX track. Excellent use has been made of the soundscape with lots of directional sound utilised, but not to a point where it becomes overbearing or seems fake.

The entire Star Wars trilogy has some of the most memorable scores in film history; created by a man who has been behind probably 9 out of 10 of the best know scores of all time, John Williams. Listening to it on DVD is like nothing you have ever heard before, it really does sounds amazing.

THE EXTRAS

There is a whole disc full of extras included in the Trilogy set that will be reviewed separately, so right here we will deal with the extra features included on this particular disc.


Besides the cool themed menu system, the only other extra is an Audio Commentary track on the disc with George Lucas, Irvin Kershner, Carrie Fisher, Ben Burtt and Dennis Muren. This commentary is fairly interesting to listen to, but I really would have loved to have a Hamill / Fisher / Ford / Lucas commentary included on the disc, that really would have been great. As it is, the commentary is a decent way to spend a couple hours and you probably will not get bored as there are no long pauses or breaks in the dialogue.

Also included on the disc, and it seems on all the Star Wars discs, is a THX system calibration option and weblinks to StarWars.com

SUMMARY

Its The Empire Strikes Back on DVD. This is of the most anticipated DVD releases of all time, even if I gave this a bad review I am sure that 99% of you will be out there buying this. Luckily this review is positive, and the DVD is excellent, I highly recommend anyone to add this film to their collection (actually not just this film, add the whole Trilogy Box Set as this is the only way you can purchase the film).


 


HOME  |  REVIEWS  |  RSS FEED  | UPCOMING  |  TWITTER  |  BLOG  |  FACEBOOK |  PRESS RELEASES  |  ABOUT US  |  SUBMIT NEWS  |  ADVERTISE  

Copyright:© Copyright in The DVD Bits is owned by the Publishers (hereby acknowledged as John Zois) unless otherwise indicated. You are entitled to use the information in The DVD Bits for your personal reference only. You must not reproduce or distribute content from The DVD Bits or any part of it, nor transmit it to any other person or incorporate it in any way in any other document, materials or other media without the expressed concent of the publishers. This site is built and maintained by John Zois, Dean Beasley, Mark Mills, Richard Gray and Al Day. Logo's shown in this site remain the copyright of their respective companies. © 1998-2009 Disclaimer: The Publishers make no undertaking as to the accuracy or correctness of information (including statements and opinions) published in The DVD Bits web site. The Publishers believe the information in The DVD Bits is correct, and they have reasonable grounds for any opinion or recommendation found within, on the date The DVD Bits was last updated. However, the Publishers are not liable for any loss or damage incurred by any person as a result of any error in any information, opinion or recommendation in The DVD Bits. The opinions expressed by individual DVD Bits team members is that of their own and not of DVD Bits. The DVD Bits accepts no responsibility for any material accessed at external sites via links on DVD Bits. All care is taken to ensure no offending, illegal or in any way harmful content is posted within the DVD Bits site however the site and site owners can not be held responsible for any such material being posted by a staff member without the expressed consent of the editor.