ONE OF AUSTRALIA'S FAVOURITE SOURCES FOR FILM, DVD AND BLU-RAY NEWS AND REVIEWS













HKDL Source
MovieXpress
Rent DVDs online - Webflicks
Adam Internet
Please Support us by Visiting our Sponsors




Doctor Who (2005) - Series 1: Volume 2
Roadshow Home Entertainment
Released on 4-Aug-2005

Reviewed by Richard Gray on 9-Aug-2005

Printable
Version



Disc Specifications
Region Coding 4
Picture Format 1.85:1 widescreen 16:9 enhanced
Audio Format(s) English DD 2
Disc-type Dual-layer
Single-sided
Non-flipper
Macrovision Yes
Subtitles English for the hearing impaired
Running Time 135 minutes (PAL)
Chapters 12
Trailer(s) None.
Commentry Track None.
Other Extras None.
Starring Christopher Eccleston
Billie Piper
Classification Rated (PG)
RRP $ 29.95

Disc Rating
Plot
Video quality
Audio quality
Extras
Overall

Richard's Recent Reviews
1.
The Back-up Plan (Blu-ray)
2.
Good Hair
3.
Blood: The Last Vampire (Blu-ray)
4.
The Last Battle (Blu-ray)
5.
Extract (Blu-ray)


THE MOVIE

Although the franchise has been going in one form or another for over forty years, at the time of writing this, Doctor Who is undergoing something of a renaissance. Thanks to the enthusiasm of Russell T. Davies, writer of Queer as Folk, The Doctor has been regenerated for a new audience. This new series has managed to appeal to both hardcore fans, as well as attracting whole new audiences, something incredibly rare on television. Respected actor Christopher Eccleston plays the Doctor, and he is joined by the surprisingly talented Billie Piper as The Doctor's companion, Rose.

This second DVD set from the new series contains episodes 4 through 6 of the new series. For my review of the first three episodes, you can read my review here.

Aliens of London/World War Three: This 2-part episode, The Doctor and Rose return from their adventures in time and space. However, while the pair believes that they have only been gone 12 hours, it seems that they have actually been gone 12 months. However, domestic drama is put aside when an alien vessel crashes into the Thames. Downing Street is locked off, and members of the cabinet begin to act strangely. Something is afoot, and it is up to The Doctor, Rose and Harriett Jones, Member for Flydale North (Penelope Wilton).

After watching countless episodes of aliens invading the home counties of England, it was great to see a full-blown 'invasion' story take place in the heart of London. Images of the alien craft smacking into Big Ben will forever be a part of WHO history. These episodes were reminiscent of the Jon Pertwee-era, in which a small band of 'people in the know' would fight off an alien menace by themselves. The special effects may have improved, but the spirit of adventure hasn't. This 2-parter is a lot of fun.

Although this is some of the finest science-fiction done for the small screen, this two-parter is not without its faults. Many have complained about the 'fart jokes', and I also feel that were completely out of step with the rest of the show. Sure, there is an in-story explanation for the excessive wind, but I just think that it lowers the tone of what is an otherwise impeccable series. The final scenes of this story, where Rose's mum waits for her to return in "10 seconds" is one of the bigger tear-jerker moments in the series (the biggest being in the forthcoming "Father's Day", found on Volume 3). It is moments like this that make the original series seem 'twee' by comparison. It is just a shame that the producers felt the need to add toilet humour to the mix, in some misguided attempt to appeal to the masses. With multi-faceted stories like this, one hardly needs fart jokes to appeal to the larger audience. Still, having now watched this 2-parter a number of times, it stands up to repeat viewing and stands out as a strong entry in this new series.

Dalek: Answering a distress call 52 levels below the Utah desert, the Doctor and Rose discover that billionaire collector Henry Van Statten has a massive museum filled with alien artifacts. Further investigation reveals that the source of the distress call was from one of the Doctor's oldest enemies - a solitary Dalek. The conflicted Doctor can't understand how the alien got there, before his worst fears come true and the Dalek escapes...

When the announcement of a new Doctor Who series after a 16 year absence came out, one of the first questions fans asked was "Will the Daleks be in it?". The estate of Terry Nation, creator of the Daleks, had the rights to the creatures tied up in legal loopholes for years. However, by the time the series started, all that had been sorted and the Doctor's biggest enemy would face him again. So was it worth the wait? When I first saw this episode, I was disappointed. The finale sees the Doctor picking up a gun and seemingly willing to use it on the Dalek, something that is completely out of character. However, re-watching this in the context of the rest of the series makes me view the episode in a different light. The Doctor is someone who has been pushed to the edge by the Daleks, and he has seen his entire race destroyed. Even the noble hero is likely to act irrationally in those circumstances. Further, a new audience gets to see how vicious one Dalek can be in this episode. This makes the season finale, involving an army of Daleks, even more chilling. Not the strongest episode in the series, but a necessary plot to show just how far these characters can be pushed emotionally.

In my review for Volume 1, I commented that this series had been a triumph from start to finish. Despite the odd hiccup (or should that be fart?) in these episodes, nothing has really happened to change my mind. What makes this new Doctor Who so appealing is a strong cast, some excellent stories and an emotional core that appeals to a broad cross-section of the television audience.

THE TRANSFER

Video:

Given that these episodes follow on directly from those on Volume 1, and come from the same source, I will repeat many of the comments I made in that review. Given that the first series finished only a few months ago in the UK, you couldn't get episodes any fresher than this. As such, this transfer looks magnificent. No film blemishes of any kind can be seen here, with a spotless image free of any flecks and specks. This is definitely going to be an advantage of living in an age of digital television.  

Colours are bright and vivid, and detail levels are high. Despite the fact that there are a few 'dark corners' explored in these episodes, detail is never lost in them. Black levels are similarly solid. There are some scenes where a great deal is happening at once, with a flurry or colours, but the transfer never has any trouble with these scenes.

Unlike the first disc, I didn't really spot any aliasing this time out. A fine show from start to finish.

Audio:

While the forthcoming season set (due out December 1st in Australia) promises to have a remixed 5.1 soundtrack, these episodes are presented here in a 'mere' Dolby Digital 2.0.

Naturally, the front speakers do all the work, although surround effects can be heard in the rear speakers. They are just more subtle than some of the more dynamic soundtracks. The soundtrack isn't designed to blow your windows out (not yet anyway), but still provides a solid mix with enough surround effects to keep you immersed in the world of The Doctor.

I still found myself having to crank the amp up occasionally for dialogue. This was not often, and it possibly the result of my self-induced deafness at the moment, but it was noticeable. Otherwise, dialogue, sound effects and music are all exceptionally clear.

THE EXTRAS

There are no extras on this disc.

Fear not, fellow WHO fans. Village/BBC DVD have announced that they will be releasing a box set at the end of the year - shaped like the TARDIS, no less - containing the entire first season and a wealth of bonus material. Fans may want to wait for that little number.

SUMMARY

Doctor Who fans will need no convincing, as they will no doubt have already bought this DVD and played it to death. Whether you are an old fan or a new one, there is no doubt that this is one of the most satisfying seasons of Doctor Who in its forty-two-year history. Only the most hardcore of fans will let the few minor quibbles I had with these episodes stand in the way of having a bloody good time.

Some may be disappointed that we only get three episodes per disc, but at 135 minutes it is still the equivalent running time to a feature film. Fans may still want to hold off until December, when a complete boxset - include bonus features - will be released.

Recommended.

 


HOME  |  REVIEWS  |  RSS FEED  | UPCOMING  |  TWITTER  |  BLOG  |  FACEBOOK |  PRESS RELEASES  |  ABOUT US  |  SUBMIT NEWS  |  ADVERTISE  

Copyright:© Copyright in The DVD Bits is owned by the Publishers (hereby acknowledged as John Zois) unless otherwise indicated. You are entitled to use the information in The DVD Bits for your personal reference only. You must not reproduce or distribute content from The DVD Bits or any part of it, nor transmit it to any other person or incorporate it in any way in any other document, materials or other media without the expressed concent of the publishers. This site is built and maintained by John Zois, Dean Beasley, Mark Mills, Richard Gray and Al Day. Logo's shown in this site remain the copyright of their respective companies. © 1998-2009 Disclaimer: The Publishers make no undertaking as to the accuracy or correctness of information (including statements and opinions) published in The DVD Bits web site. The Publishers believe the information in The DVD Bits is correct, and they have reasonable grounds for any opinion or recommendation found within, on the date The DVD Bits was last updated. However, the Publishers are not liable for any loss or damage incurred by any person as a result of any error in any information, opinion or recommendation in The DVD Bits. The opinions expressed by individual DVD Bits team members is that of their own and not of DVD Bits. The DVD Bits accepts no responsibility for any material accessed at external sites via links on DVD Bits. All care is taken to ensure no offending, illegal or in any way harmful content is posted within the DVD Bits site however the site and site owners can not be held responsible for any such material being posted by a staff member without the expressed consent of the editor.