ONE OF AUSTRALIA'S FAVOURITE SOURCES FOR DVD NEWS, REVIEWS AND RESOURCES













HKDL Source
MovieXpress
Rent DVDs online - Webflicks
Adam Internet
Please Support us by Visiting our Sponsors




Fiddler On The Roof
MGM/UA
Released on 10-Jan-2000

Reviewed by Sarah McKinlay on 1-Feb-2000

Printable
Version



Disc Specifications
Region Coding 4
Picture Format 2.35:1 widescreen 16:9 enhanced
Audio Format(s) English DD 5.1
French DD 1
Italian DD 1
Spanish DD 5.1
Disc-type Dual-layer
Single-sided
Non-flipper
Macrovision Yes
Subtitles English for the hearing impaired
English
Spanish
Dutch
Finnish
Norwegian
Polish
Swedish
French
Running Time 174 minutes (PAL)
Chapters 36
Trailer(s) Yes - theatrical
Commentry Track Yes - Director Norman Jewison and Topol
Other Extras Collectable booklet, Picture disc
Starring Topol, Norma Crane, Leonard Frey, Molly Picon, Paul Mann
Classification Rated (G)
RRP $ 34.95

Disc Rating
Plot
Video quality
Audio quality
Extras
Overall

Sarah's Recent Reviews
1.
Out for Justice
2.
A Fish Called Wanda
3.
West Side Story
4.
At First Sight
5.
Quiz Show


THE MOVIE

This is the story of a small community which is devestated by oppression. A small Jewish community, where the old faith is the foundation of the community.

While being a musical masterpiece, the story is centred around Tevye (Topol), the local milkman and the love for his family. It shows the love of one family and how they survive being driven out of their homeland.

As a small town isolated from the rest of the world, they receive minimal news from a newspaper which only one man in the town can read.

As Tevye's daughters grow up, they hope for a perfect match from the matchmaker. With their own expectations, their parents must except a changing world and that old traditions are being challenged by their children.

THE TRANSFER

Video:

This is another issue on a classic film onto DVD. Warner have a mixed-bag at how well they pull this off and Fiddler On The Roof is one of the better ones.

The movie is from 1971, so a few little niggly film faults are to be expected. There are a reasonable number of film artefacts such as specs and dust. Telecine wobble was kept to an absolute minimum - some modern films could learn from this.

The shadow detail is a little lacking in clarity making the film feel a little 'washed-out'. Some scenes are excellent, other not so crash hot. For example, in chapter 5 when Topol sings "If I were a rich man", the picture is excellent. No compression or film faults to be found. But then in chapter 6, the screen is riddled with compression artefacts. A bit topsy terby if you ask me.

Colours are pretty much muted throughout, but this suits the mood of the film, so I assume it is intentional.

Compression faults were to be seen here and there. No big deal and certainly not bad enough to trash the whole transfer.

This is nearly a 3 hour movie, so at least we got it all on 1 side of the disc (shame we can't say that about ALL Warner discs).

The picture is anamorphically enhanced (to my surprise), but I can't help but feel if they were so pushed for space why they didn't drop anamorphic and trade it for a better quality picture encoded at a high rate.

Audio:

Another remastered soundtrack here. The score has been remixed into 5.1 channels for this release and, as is usual with this style of movie, the music is where the new soundtrack is apparent.

Surrounds are used for ambience in the music score, and the front soundstage is used to widen the experience. This is pretty much the common thing to do when remastering soundtracks at the moment.

I'm not sure if the purests will agree that this works, but it certainly gives the film more "feeling" and emotion.

Interestingly the dialogue is NOT restricted to the center channel, but rather spread across the front soundstage.

Sub-woofer usage, like the surrounds, is called into use for the musical score only.

THE EXTRAS

Theatrical Trailer - Provides a nice overview of the movie and introduces the catchy music used in this amazing movie.

Commentary track - 3 hours worth of listening to Topol mostly talk about what happened on set and stories about most of the poeple who were involved on and off set. Moderatly interesting.

SUMMARY

If you enjoy musicals, this is another one for the collection. I enjoyed the music and the storyline is very powerful.

You have to applaude the fact that such a movie is being preserved by being put on DVD. This is a movie with a storyline that we should never forget.

I give this movie the thumbs up.

 


HOME  |  REVIEWS  |  RSS FEED  | UPCOMING  |  TWITTER  |  BLOG  |  FACEBOOK |  PRESS RELEASES  |  ABOUT US  |  SUBMIT NEWS  |  ADVERTISE  

Copyright:© Copyright in The DVD Bits is owned by the Publishers (hereby acknowledged as John Zois) unless otherwise indicated. You are entitled to use the information in The DVD Bits for your personal reference only. You must not reproduce or distribute content from The DVD Bits or any part of it, nor transmit it to any other person or incorporate it in any way in any other document, materials or other media without the expressed concent of the publishers. This site is built and maintained by John Zois, Dean Beasley, Mark Mills, Richard Gray and Al Day. Logo's shown in this site remain the copyright of their respective companies. © 1998-2009 Disclaimer: The Publishers make no undertaking as to the accuracy or correctness of information (including statements and opinions) published in The DVD Bits web site. The Publishers believe the information in The DVD Bits is correct, and they have reasonable grounds for any opinion or recommendation found within, on the date The DVD Bits was last updated. However, the Publishers are not liable for any loss or damage incurred by any person as a result of any error in any information, opinion or recommendation in The DVD Bits. The opinions expressed by individual DVD Bits team members is that of their own and not of DVD Bits. The DVD Bits accepts no responsibility for any material accessed at external sites via links on DVD Bits. All care is taken to ensure no offending, illegal or in any way harmful content is posted within the DVD Bits site however the site and site owners can not be held responsible for any such material being posted by a staff member without the expressed consent of the editor.